The Morally Grey Character: Why We Love Them

Discover the allure of morally grey characters in fantasy literature. Explore why these complex, unpredictable, and flawed anti-heroes captivate readers, challenge our perceptions of morality, and keep us hooked on every twist and betrayal.

In the murky depths of fantasy literature, there exists a breed of character that captures our hearts.

If only because they’ve already stolen it when we weren’t looking.

These are the morally grey characters.

The ones who straddle the line between hero and villain with all the grace of a cat walking a tightrope over a pit of hungry crocodiles.

But what is it about these dubious darlings that makes us love them so much?

The Charm of a Well-Timed Betrayal

Nothing spices up a story quite like a character who can’t be trusted.

We, the readers, become like detectives, piecing together clues.

We try to anticipate when our favourite morally grey character will stab their best friend in the back—or, you know, just borrow their sword without asking.

It’s this unpredictability that keeps us glued to the page.

Who doesn’t enjoy the occasional bout of paranoia?

When a character who’s been playing nice suddenly reveals a darker side, it’s like finding out that your charming neighbour collects antique guillotines.

Sure, it’s concerning, but it’s also fascinating.

You can’t help but want to learn more.

The morally grey character thrives on this duality.

They make us question our own sense of morality as we cheer for them while simultaneously hoping we never meet them in a dark alley.

Complexity Makes for Better Conversations

Let’s be honest: the morally grey character is the life of the fantasy dinner party.

While the pure hero is off discussing the virtues of honour and justice (yawn), our grey friend is regaling the crowd with tales of ethical dilemmas and questionable choices.

And let’s face it, when was the last time you stayed up all night debating whether it’s okay to steal bread to feed your starving family?

Now, how about whether it’s okay to overthrow a corrupt government by any means necessary?

That’ll keep the ale flowing.

Morally grey characters force us to confront the uncomfortable truth that morality isn’t black and white.

Instead, it’s a thousand shades of questionable decisions.

They push us to think deeper, to empathise with characters we might otherwise despise.

They make us realise that, in the end, everyone’s just doing their best—or their worst—with the cards they’ve been dealt.

Relatability in Flaws

If there’s one thing morally grey characters are good at, it’s making us feel better about our own questionable life choices.

Didn’t return that library book on time?

No worries—at least you didn’t orchestrate a coup to seize the throne.

We see ourselves in these characters, not because we all secretly dream of world domination, but because we understand that life isn’t always as straightforward as we’d like it to be.

Their flaws make them human, even when they’re, well, not human.

These characters remind us that perfection is overrated.

Sometimes the best stories come from those who’ve made a few mistakes along the way.

Or a few hundred.

They’re the embodiment of the idea that it’s not where you start, but where you end up—and how many bodies you leave in your wake.

The Thrill of Redemption—Or Not

Ah, redemption arcs.

The bread and butter of many a fantasy novel.

But with morally grey characters, redemption isn’t a given.

It’s more of a “maybe if the stars align and they’re in a particularly generous mood” kind of thing.

And that’s what keeps us hooked.

Will they find their way back to the light, or will they sink further into the shadows?

It’s like watching a cat decide whether or not to push a priceless vase off the edge of a table.

There’s a good chance they’ll do it, but there’s also a chance they’ll simply walk away, leaving you in suspense.

The possibility of redemption adds an extra layer of tension to the story.

When a morally grey character does something good, we’re left wondering if this is the start of their path to righteousness.

Or just a brief detour before they get back to their usual nefarious activities.

And when they don’t find redemption?

Well, that’s just as satisfying, because sometimes it’s nice to see someone embrace their inner darkness with the kind of gusto usually reserved for eating the last slice of cake.

The Allure of the Anti-Hero

Let’s face it, the classic hero can be a bit… predictable.

They’re bound by a code of honour, always doing the right thing, never straying from the path of righteousness.

Yawn.

The morally grey character, on the other hand, is the wild card of the deck.

They do what needs to be done, consequences be damned.

They’re the ones who’ll make the tough choices, the sacrifices, and maybe even a deal with the devil—literally or figuratively.

There’s something undeniably appealing about a character who isn’t afraid to get their hands dirty.

They’re the ones we love to hate, and sometimes, just love.

Because deep down, we all know that in a world full of heroes, it’s the anti-heroes who keep things interesting.

They’re the ones who make us question our own morals.

They challenge our perceptions.

In the end, they remind us that sometimes, the world isn’t as simple as good versus evil.

Why We Keep Coming Back

In the end, we love morally grey characters because they’re the ones who make fantasy worlds feel real.

They’re complex, flawed, and utterly fascinating.

They challenge us, surprise us, and occasionally horrify us, but we wouldn’t have it any other way.

So here’s to the characters who walk the line between light and dark.

And to the readers who follow them into the shadows, hoping for the best but expecting the worst.

After all, if there’s one thing we can count on, it’s that morally grey characters will always keep us on our toes.

And really, isn’t that what we’re all here for?

The Trope of the Underdog in Fantasy Literature

Explore the captivating world of underdogs in fantasy literature, where unlikely heroes from Frodo Baggins to Vin take center stage. Discover how these relatable characters, with their struggles and triumphs, add depth and resonance to fantasy tales, making them more engaging and inspiring for readers.

In the grand arena of fantasy literature, where heroes are often as muscular and shiny as a knight’s armour, the underdog stands out like a sore thumb – albeit a determined, plucky sore thumb.

The trope of the underdog is as prevalent in fantasy as misplaced magic wands, offering a narrative arc as satisfying as finding a secret room in a haunted castle.

A Hero Unlikely to Win, But Tries Anyway

The underdog is typically as well-equipped for their journey as a knight heading into battle armed with a teaspoon.

They’re the farm boy who’s more familiar with pigs than dragons, the scrawny apprentice who can barely lift a sword, or the unassuming hobbit who’s never ventured beyond their front garden.

These characters embark on quests that seem about as well-advised as a stroll through a dragon’s den wearing armour made of gold.

Why We Root for the Underdog

There’s something inherently appealing about cheering on someone who’s about as likely to succeed as a snowball in a furnace.

Perhaps it’s their tenacity in the face of insurmountable odds, or maybe it’s just human nature to support the little guy.

After all, who hasn’t felt like an underdog at some point, battling the metaphorical dragons of our everyday lives?

Notable Underdogs in Fantasy

Frodo Baggins in ‘The Lord of the Rings‘: A hobbit who’d much rather be at home but ends up carrying the most dangerous item in the world.

Neville Longbottom in ‘Harry Potter‘: The boy who was almost the Chosen One, but turned out to be a hero in his own right, proving that bravery comes in different forms.

Vin in ‘Mistborn‘: A street urchin who discovers she has powers that could change the world, despite her initial disbelief in her own abilities.

The Underdog’s Journey: A Reflection of Real Life

The underdog’s journey often mirrors our own struggles.

They don’t just face external foes; they battle self-doubt, fear, and the disbelief of those around them.

Their victories are as much about overcoming their inner demons as they are about defeating the dark lord or evil empire.

The Impact on Fantasy Literature

The underdog trope has nudged fantasy literature away from the omnipotent, flawless hero towards more relatable, flawed characters.

It’s introduced a level of humanity and vulnerability to fantasy that allows readers to see a bit of themselves in the characters.

It reminds us that sometimes, the greatest power lies not in strength or magic, but in resilience and the courage to keep going, even when the odds are about as favourable as a picnic in a troll’s cave.

The Lasting Appeal of the Underdog

In the world of fantasy literature, the underdog continues to reign supreme, a testament to the enduring appeal of seeing the least likely amongst us rise to the challenge.

They remind us that heroism comes in all shapes and sizes, often emerging from the most unlikely of places.

In celebrating the underdog, fantasy literature doesn’t just tell us a story; it gives us hope – hope that even the smallest among us can change the world, armed with nothing but courage and a teaspoon.

Embracing the Morally Grey: A New Era in Fantasy Literature

Explore the rise of morally grey protagonists in fantasy literature, where characters challenge traditional notions of heroism. Delve into the world of complex, flawed heroes who reflect the nuanced realities of morality, shaping a new, more relatable and thrilling landscape in modern fantasy fiction.

Once upon a time in fantasy literature, heroes were as pure and straightforward as a glass of milk in a monastery.

Then came the rise of the morally grey protagonist, as welcome in the genre as a goblin at a fairy convention.

These characters brought a complexity to fantasy that was previously reserved for tax legislation, making the line between good and evil as blurry as a drunkard’s vision.

From White Knights to Grey Squires

Gone are the days when a hero’s armour shone brighter than their morals.

Modern fantasy has embraced protagonists who are less ‘knight in shining armour’ and more ‘person in mildly tarnished chainmail’.

These are characters who might save the world, but only after they’ve finished their pint and had a long think about whether the world is worth saving.

The Lure of the Grey

What is it about these morally ambiguous characters that captures our imagination?

Perhaps it’s their relatable nature.

After all, who among us is without sin, or at least a few parking tickets?

Or maybe it’s the unpredictability they bring to a story – a welcome reprieve from the good old days when you could predict a hero’s actions with the reliability of a train timetable.

Examples in the Wild

Take George R.R. Martin’s “A Song of Ice and Fire” series, where characters frequently change sides, and you’re never quite sure who to root for.

Or Joe Abercrombie’s “The First Law” trilogy, starring a barbarian with a conscience and a torturer with a heart.

These characters are as morally consistent as a politician’s promises.

The Appeal of the Dark Side

The rise of the morally grey protagonist also reflects a shift in societal norms.

In an age where we’re used to seeing heroes fall and villains rise on the evening news, these characters offer a mirror to our own world – albeit a slightly smudged one.

They remind us that life is rarely black and white, but an endless spectrum of greys.

Impact on the Genre

This new breed of protagonist has revolutionised fantasy literature, leading to richer, more complex narratives.

It’s an evolution from fairy tale simplicity to a genre that recognises the multifaceted nature of humanity.

And let’s face it, it’s just more fun to read about a hero who might save the princess or might just pawn her crown for a quick buck.

Long Live the Grey!

The rise of morally grey protagonists in fantasy literature marks a maturation of the genre.

These characters, with their complex motivations and questionable morals, offer a more nuanced exploration of the human condition.

They prove that sometimes, the most interesting path isn’t the high road or the low road, but the winding path that meanders somewhere in between.

In the end, isn’t that a bit like life itself?

Unlock Exclusive Content and Early Access with Jon Cronshaw’s Ream Community

Embark on a thrilling journey through Jon Cronshaw’s immersive speculative fiction universe. Discover character-driven tales, exclusive content, and a passionate community of readers.

Hey there, fellow adventurers!

I’m Jon Cronshaw, a storyteller who crafts tales that blend the grit and darkness of reality with the wonder and excitement of speculative fiction.

From epic fantasy adventures to post-apocalyptic struggles, I create character-driven stories that explore the depths of the human experience.

Immerse yourself in stories that don’t shy away from the harsh realities of life, while also celebrating the power of hope, friendship, and perseverance.

By joining my Ream channel, you’ll embark on a journey through rich, immersive worlds filled with flawed heroes, complex relationships, and heart-pounding action.

You’ll get:

🔥 Early Access: Be among the first to experience my latest works, diving into new adventures before anyone else.

📚 Consistent Updates: You’ll receive at least one story update per week, though it will most likely end up being more. I’m committed to delivering a steady stream of content to keep you engaged and entertained.

🌟 Exclusive Content: Unlock access to stories and behind-the-scenes insights that are only available to my subscribers. It’s your key to a deeper understanding of the worlds and characters I create.

💬 Community Engagement: Connect with a vibrant community of fellow readers who share your passion for character-driven stories. Discuss your favorite moments, speculate about upcoming twists, and dive deep into the themes that resonate with you.

When you join my channel, you’re not just gaining access to a collection of stories—you’re becoming part of a community that celebrates the power of storytelling.

So, if you’re ready to embark on a journey of self-discovery and adventure, hit that subscribe button and join me on a voyage through the realms of speculative fiction.

Together, we’ll explore the light and the dark, the grit and the wonder, and everything in between.

Let the adventure begin!

Jon

P.S. Not ready to subscribe just yet? No worries! You can follow my channel for free and gain access to a selection of stories. It’s a great way to get a taste of the adventures that await.

Wizard of the Wasteland – chapter one (excerpt)

Experience the gripping post-apocalyptic world of Jon Cronshaw’s “Wizard of the Wasteland” in the first chapter reveal. Join Abel as he fights for survival, battles addiction, and encounters enslaved children. Discover a world of hope and despair in this thrilling sci-fi novel.

Wizard of the Wasteland by Jon Cronshaw

The stranger rolled into town at dawn, his cart rumbling through the gap in Trinity’s towering fence.

Abel squinted at the sun’s orange glare as it rose over the rooftops. “Come on, Pip.” He patted his thigh as a brindle-furred dog looked up at him and ran in a tight circle, her tail wagging. He passed huddled shacks as people gravitated towards the arrival.

Abel followed the gently sloping dirt track towards the entrance as Pip trotted at his side. Trinity wasn’t his home, but they always gave him a bed and meal when he came to trade.

Chickens darted in haphazard zigzags, confined by a line of wire mesh to his right, shedding feathers as they avoided the dog. The looming crucifix beyond the fence spread shadows across the rooftops. Children ducked past him, laughing as they chased each other.

A brown and grey mule lumbered forward, its head bowed as its rider brought the cart to a halt. The cart rocked on four rubber tyres. Garish daubs of blue and gold paint stretched along its sides.

Engulfed by dusty blue robes, the man dropped from the cart, reached behind his seat, and pulled on a pointy blue hat. He turned to the residents. “Ladies and gentlemen. I am the Great Alfonso, Wizard of the Wasteland.”

Abel joined the edge of the crowd as Pip sniffed around behind him, unconcerned by the wizard. Pip had been with him since he got off plez. She was the best reason he had to stay clean.

People stepped aside for Trinity’s priestess, Sal, as she moved through the crowd to speak to the wizard, her dreadlocks hanging loose from her hooded robe.

The wizard offered her a grin. “My good lady, am I correct in assuming that you are the Sal these good people have been talking about?”

“That’s right.” She folded her arms. “And you are…?”

The wizard removed his hat with a flourish and bowed his head. His skin was darker than Sal’s, his hair an explosion of twisted curls, streaked in black and grey. He raised his yellow-tinged eyes to meet Sal’s gaze. “Madam, if you please, I am sure my reputation precedes me. I am the Wizard of the Wasteland.” He lifted his chin, offering her a toothy smile as he spread his arms wide. “I am the magnificent, the splendiferous, the incomparable, Great Alfonso.”

Sal shook her head, letting the silence hang in the air for a long, awkward moment. “Sorry, I’ve never heard of you.” She examined his cart, running a finger along the whorls of paint. “Are you a trader?”

“Yes, yes.” The wizard raised his voice and a finger. “But more.” He smiled again and swept his gaze across the gathered faces. “What I offer is the wonder of the Great Alfonso’s magical extravaganza.” He threw out his arms.

Abel smirked as a few titters spread behind him. What was this guy trying to pull? He’d seen his fair share of chancers and conmen, but this was something else.

“Magical what?” Sal tilted her head.

“What I have for you today, ladies and gentlemen, is the culmination of many years of tireless research into the arcane arts of magic and alchemy, a glimpse into our once great past, now long lost to dust.” The wizard grabbed a handful of soil and let it fall between his fingers.

“I still don’t understand.”

“My good lady, you strike me as an intelligent woman, which is why I will ask you to be my first volunteer.”

She looked around and shrugged. “Okay.”

The wizard shuffled around the side of his cart, unbolting a series of locks. An oak panel swung down on a pair of hinges, bouncing for a moment against its supporting ropes.

The onlookers moved in closer as the wizard arranged apparent junk along a series of shelves—an ancient television set with a curved grey screen and wood panel casing, a fish tank, and a hand generator in black and brass.

Abel raised his eyebrows at the objects, wondering where the wizard acquired them. The electrical items would be useless, but some of those things were worth a lot in trade.

The wizard lifted a toy car from the shelf, its red paint faded to a cloudy pink along its edges. He retrieved a key and made a show of pushing it into the car’s rear. “With this ancient and magical key, I can bring power to this otherwise inanimate object.” He placed the car flat on the panel and turned the key, the mechanism clicking and crunching. The wizard muttered an incantation, closed his eyes, and wriggled his fingers over the toy. He let go. The car shot forward and hurtled over the edge, landing in a clump of soft grass.

A few people applauded.

“Thank you, thank you. You are all most gracious.” He lowered his head and returned the car to its shelf. “What you’ve seen here is just a mere hint, a mere glimmer of the extent of my magical powers.”

He took something else down, turned to the crowd, and raised a pair of binoculars above his head. “Behold! These magical eye lenses allow their user to see objects that are far away as though they are right in front of their very eyes.” He handed the binoculars to Sal and showed her how to look through them, gesturing for her to point them towards the spherical form at the top of the water tower.

A hush dropped over the crowd as she looked through the lenses. “These are wonderful. Where did you find them?”

“That, madam, is a secret.” The wizard tapped his nose with a forefinger. “Please, pass those round. Let the other members of your wonderful community experience this glimpse into the possibilities of alchemy and magic. But, please, do be careful.”

People took turns looking through the lenses. Abel smiled at the gasps of awe and the occasional burst of laughter. When they reached him, he focused on the wizard rifling around one of the shelves. He looked down at a tug to his elbow.

A kid jumped up and down with eager excitement, clapping his hands and staring at the binoculars. He handed them to the boy, took a moment to show him how to use them, and turned his attention back to the wizard.

The wizard held up a light bulb. “As you will observe, this is a simple globe of glass. I would offer to hand this round so you can witness for yourself my ingenious design. But, because the magic is so powerful and so very dangerous, I will instead ask that you all take a few paces back to give me room to perform this most incredible and delicate of feats.”

He placed the light bulb on the panel and checked the wires were connected to the hand generator. He stepped over to the dynamo and muttered an incantation with a raised chin and half-closed eyes.

Smiling to the crowd, he wound the handle.

A low hum and sharp crackle of electricity emanated from the generator as he turned the handle.

A scattering of gasps spread around the wizard as the light bulb glowed a brownish-yellow.

“As you can see, with this ancient magic, I have created fire within this glass. I’m sure you will agree that this might be the most marvellous, magnificent, magical accomplishment you have ever had the good fortune to witness.”

He stopped abruptly, sweeping his gaze across the crowd, now rapt. He raised his right forefinger with a sudden jerk. “Oh, but there is more.” He made a dramatic turn, his robes billowing in an expanse of dusty blue.

The crowd moved forward with hesitant steps as they strained to get a closer look.

The wizard disconnected the wires from the light bulb, placed it in a pot filled with cloths on the middle shelf, and connected the wires to the television. He turned back to the crowd, spreading his arms wide. “I must ask again that you take a few steps back. This is very ancient and powerful magic. What I am about to show you is the most amazing sight. Where are the magical lenses?” He waited a few moments for the binoculars to return to him. He looked through them, smiled again, and placed them on a shelf. “With those lenses, you were able to make objects far away seem as though they were close enough to touch. Using the same principles, I have devised and constructed a magical box that allows you to see over great distances to lands to the west, beyond the lawless zone.”

He reached for the hand generator and cranked the handle again.

The belt hummed, crackling and sparking as the smell of burning rubber filled the air.

He leaned over to the television set, muttered a spell, pushed a button, and kept turning the handle.

White noise hissed from the television’s speaker as the screen came to life in a random array of white, black, and grey—a dead signal. “As you could see, ladies and gentlemen, what we are witnessing is a window into another land, another land shrouded in—what is it?” He tilted his head and rubbed his chin. “A dust storm, perhaps?” He dropped the handle and turned to the audience with a dramatic shrug.

The white noise fell to silence, the screen fading to black. The gathered crowd applauded as the wizard made a deep bow. “Thank you, thank you. You are all too kind.”

“What I am about to show you now may be my greatest miracle, the pinnacle of my magical achievements.” His expression turned grim. “I warn you all that this is ancient and powerful magic and urge you again to stand back.” He reached up to the fish tank on the top shelf and took it down, placing it carefully on the flat panel.

He pulled out a green frog, holding it up by one leg for the audience to see, its body squirming as its free leg flailed wildly.

Stepping over to Sal, he dangled the frog before her. “Madam, please do me the honour of telling the members of your wonderful community what you see before you.”

She glanced over her shoulder and shrugged. “It’s just a frog.”

“It’s just a frog! Never has a truer phrase been uttered. So you will agree that this is a living, breathing frog? You agree there is no trickery, no shenanigans? It is, as you say, ‘just a frog’?”

She nodded. “As I say, it’s just a frog.”

Without ceremony, the wizard swung the frog against the panel. He waited with his back to the crowd for several seconds and raised the lifeless body for all to see. “As you will observe, the life of this frog has been taken.”

He turned his attention back to Sal. “Madam, would you like to take a moment to examine this frog, to assure the ladies and gentlemen gathered that this is the same frog?”

“You killed one of God’s creatures. I wouldn’t call that magic.”

“And you would be correct in that most astute of observations.” He offered her a slight bow. “There is no magic in killing a frog, but as much as it pains me to do it, as much as it pains me to take the life of an innocent creature, it was unfortunately a necessary component of the Great Alfonso’s most important magical discovery.”

The crowd looked on in silence as the wizard laid the frog flat. He took the wires from the television, attached the crocodile clips to the frog’s torso, and muttered the words of a magic spell, making complex shapes and symbols in the air with his fingers.

He turned to the crowd, made a solemn expression, removed his hat, and bowed. “Observe.” His voice dropped to little more than a whisper.

He stepped over to the generator and turned the handle, building up a rhythm until the belt hummed again.

The frog’s right leg twitched. The wizard wound the handle faster, smiling when the frog convulsed, its arms and legs quivering spasmodically.

Dropping the handle, he placed his hat back on his head and turned to the audience. “As you have seen, ladies and gentlemen, the Great Alfonso has brought this frog back from the dead.”

He turned back to the frog, now limp, and dropped it into the fish tank. He faced the crowd, taking in the applause. “Thank you.”

A few men shook their heads and walked away.

Children ran over to the wizard, jumping up and down as they asked him questions.

The wizard closed his cart.

Abel smiled at the wizard and weaved through the crowd, making his way over to Sal. “What did you make of that?”

She sniffed. “He’s clearly a charlatan.”

“Yep. But he certainly knows how to put on a show.”

“It’s just technology from before the end times. There’s no magic to it.” Her eyes grew narrow as a few residents led the wizard’s mule away to be fed and watered.

“I know.” Abel rubbed his beard, trying to understand her hostility. “But you have to admit, it’s pretty fascinating stuff.”

A frown spread across her face. “You’re not seduced by this fraudster, are you?”

“No.” His protest came out more defensive than he would have liked. “I’m intrigued. It’s been a long time since I’ve seen anything with real electricity.”

Sal nodded. “Perhaps.”

A tall man with pale skin and dark hair wandered over.

Abel forced a smile. “Jacob.”

“You look healthy. I take it you’re still keeping clean?”

“Yep.” He bristled at the implication in Jacob’s tone. He’d been clean for over a year, but it was the same question every time he returned to Trinity. They were good people, and the settlement was the best place to trade this side of the Grid. “I’m just going about my business as usual. No plez for me.” He knelt next to Pip and rubbed the fur behind her neck. At least she never judged him.

“Good to hear. God willing, let’s hope you can stay that way.” One corner of his mouth twitched as he turned to Sal. “What’s the plan with our wizard friend?”

Sal shook her head and sighed. “I don’t know. The residents are clearly taken with him. Might cause friction if we ask him to leave.”

Jacob cast a cursory glance towards the wizard. “What do you say? We treat him like any other trader and hope he goes by the morning.”

“I don’t trust him.”

“Come on, Sal.” Abel gestured towards the fence. “It’s hard out there. He’s surviving. It’s different, I’ll grant you, but he’s not raiding, or dealing. He looks like he’s probably clean.”

She raised her hands. “You could be right. But, I still don’t like it. This promotion of magic and mysticism doesn’t sit well with me.”

Abel smirked. “Just a different kind of magic to what you’re used to. You’ve got God, this guy’s got…” His voice trailed off at Sal’s glare.

She turned to Jacob. “He can stay for breakfast, but then I want him gone.”